Advocate for Mom & Dad

  • Home
  • Caregiving
    • Caregiver Stories
  • Healthcare
  • Finances
  • Legal
  • Family Dynamics
    • Blog
  • Safety
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Books and Products
    • Contact Deb / Blog Contributor Sign-up
    • Helpful Forms and Documents
    • Helpful Resources and Websites
      • Home Care Services
    • Programs
    • Podcast, Videos and Radio Programs
  • About
    • About Deb Hallisey
    • Our Family Story
    • Contact Information
    • Contributors
    • Testimonials
    • Welcome Video

The Conversation Caregivers Dread the Most – Convincing an Elder to Stop Driving.

June 28, 2021 by Debra Hallisey

The Conversation Caregivers Dread the Most – Convincing an Elder to Stop Driving.

An objective third party can help.

Giving up driving is a tangible loss of independence for your elder. It’s no wonder they resist the topic. If you are truly worried about not only the safety of your elder, but everyone else on the road, then understanding what motivates them can help initiate the conversation. If finances motivate them, talking about how much you pay for car insurance and the increased cost of gasoline can be the start of moving them from no to yes. They may be secretly concerned about the safety of others when they drive, so an expression of concern about driving at night can be another motivator.

Either way, I suspect in very few instances will your loved one just give up the keys. This is where a disinterested third party can be a huge help in one of the most elemental and difficult conversations. A third party does not have the emotional investment of family members, nor are they caught up in family dynamics. They can have a rational discussion in a way that helps an elder decide not to drive. As much as possible, they can keep the control with you elder and allow them to make the decision to stop driving.

Getting your loved one to take a formal driving evaluation can be an uphill battle when it means leaving the home and getting on the road. If that is the case, consider the program “Beyond Driving with Dignity.” This program was developed by a former state policeman in Ohio and is owned by Senior Care Authority. It helps seniors self-assess if they are at risk for a vehicle accident and it does the evaluation in their own home. Being in familiar territory can go a long way in getting them to agree, especially in cases of dementia when new environments are stressful.

A 2.5 to 3 hour assessment.

  1. Conversation

The assessment starts with a conversation designed to learn about the driver and to give them a level of comfort with the tester. Open ended questions like “Tell me about where you grew up” or “What was the first car you owned” allows the elder time for “legacy processing” through the retelling of fond memories. Legacy processing is an evaluation of our lives and is one of the last developmental tasks that we do. This conversational technique opens the door for the elder to reevaluate their lives, including driving, while it keeps the control of the conversation with them.

During this conversation, the tester is looking for holes or inconsistencies in the story telling. Not being able to name where they worked for 40 years is a red flag.

  • Driving Assessments

The remaining time together moves into driving assessments, which do not require getting behind the wheel. One of the most telling assessments is a clock test, developed by Dr. Barbara Fraud, it is an indicator of cognitive impairment. Studies show the inability to do this task puts the elder at an elevated risk for getting behind the wheel.

 For this test, the elder is given a piece of paper with the following instructions:

  1. Draw the face of the clock.
  2. Add the numbers to the clock.
  3. Mark the clock at 11:10.

The clock test may sound simple, but it requires executing all the steps correctly and in the right order, a processing ability that gets progressively worse for anyone living with Alzheimer’s and other forms of dementia.

The second test, the Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE), is used by many professionals to assess cognitive skills. You are probably familiar with a physician asking an older loved one questions like “What day is it?” or “Who is the president?”. Executing simple tasks is another skill assessed by the MMSE. For example, a list of three words is given (apple, chair, car) and the elder is asked to repeat them. In ten minutes they are asked to name the three items again.

The final assessment is the Snellgrove Maze task designed by Dr. Carol Snellgrove to test attention, visuoconstructional ability and the executive functions of planning and foresight. This simple pencil and paper test has the elder navigate a maze without crossing lines or back tracking.

3.      Written report

The result is a written report with recommendations. About one third of the respondents are fine to drive with limitations, like staying off highways or not driving at night. Another two thirds should not be driving and are advised they are at an elevated risk to be in a vehicle accident.

If they are at an elevated risk, the tester might say “it is my suggestion that you retire from driving.” This is followed up with the objective data to support why the suggestion was made. The goal is to get the person to acknowledge and decide for themselves to stop. The report is given to the person who completed the self-assessment and, with permission, is shared with family members and doctors.

Ideally, the tester and driver would sit with the family and let them know the decision. At this point, the conversation turns to how the person will get around. A discussion around transportation help from family, friends, home care agencies and service businesses like GoGo Grandparent follows.   At no point is the elder to feel “stranded.”

If you are concerned about your elder driving and they are adamant about not taking a behind-the-wheel test, for a $350.00 investment you can have them tested at home. Then based on the results, gain their cooperation or, at the very least, move a conversation about driving forward.

With thanks to David Stamberg of Senior Care Authority for his help in writing this article.

Jump To Top


 
Deb is available as a caregiver consultant. She will answer the question: “Where do I start?” and find the resources to alleviate your stress. If you would like to invest a half hour to learn how she can help you, please contact her at: Free 30 minute consulting call

Deb is the author of “Your Caregiver Relationship Contract.” This book explains how to have an intentional conversation and how unspoken expectations can cause communication problems. Click here to learn more about Your Caregiver Relationship Contract.

  • Tweet
  • Share 0
  • Reddit
  • +1
  • Pinterest 0
  • LinkedIn 0
  • Email

Filed Under: Safety Tagged With: advocate for mom and dad, Certified Caregiver Consultant, how can I get dad to stop driving, I am worried about my parents driving, Mom will not take a road driving test, New Jersey, New York, pennsylvania, what driving ability tests are there for seniors, what is beyond driving with dignity

About Debra Hallisey

Deb Hallisey is a caregiver knowledge expert. She earned this title helping her dad through his congestive heart failure and death. She continues to earn it as caregiver for her disabled mother. Deb brings a unique perspective to this educational blog. She has over twenty-five years’ experience as a consultant with Ernst & Young and Huron Consulting Group along with smaller boutique firms building and enhancing corporate training programs. Deb is an educator with a passion for helping others advocate for older adults and their families. Read more about Deb.

Comments

  1. Matt Gurwell says

    July 1, 2021 at 7:19 pm

    Another great article, Debra! For families concerned about a loved one’s driving, know that the “Beyond Driving with Dignity” program is available throughout the country. Interested families can learn more by visiting https://www.beyonddrivingwithdignity.com.

    • Debra Hallisey says

      July 2, 2021 at 1:08 am

      Thank you Matt for the link and the great work you do.

Text Size:

Zoom in Regular Zoom out
Caregiver Blogs
  • Your Caregiver Relationship Contract
  • Frontier_ad_320X450
  • Senior Care Authority ad
Boomer Benefits

Popular posts

  • The Medicare 100 day Rule Impacts Post Hospital Stays
  • Smart Strategies for the HIPAA Privacy Law
  • Medicaid’s Five Year Look Back: 6 Tips On How You Can Prepare Now
  • DNR, DNI, DNH, POLST – The Alphabet Soup of Advance Directives
  • Acute Care (Hospital), Inpatient Acute Rehabilitation (IRF), Sub-Acute, SNF, LTC, LTAC – The Alphabet Soup of Care Facilities.
Privacy Policy      Disclaimer

Sign up for our newsletter!

Our monthly newsletter is filled with additional tips about caregiving from thought leaders. Updates on key legislation, changes in laws, book and video resources are delivered to right to your inbox.

Thanks so much for subscribing to our newsletter.

CONTACT INFORMATION

Deb Hallisey is a caregiving consultant available for advisory services, speaking engagements, and guest blog articles.

To reach out to Deb:
Advocate for Mom and Dad LLC
P.O. Box 55340
2601 Brunswick Pike
Lawrenceville, NJ 08638

deb@advocateformomanddad.com

@advocatemomdad

Copyright © 2023 Advocate for Mom and Dad.  All Rights Reserved.  Website by Blue Kite Web Solutions LLC..